As part of an investigation into the governance and financial management of Magdalen College School, I read online profiles of the Master, Helen Pike.

Why are all the articles about her so gushing? She’s a public figure making political decisions about the future of one of England’s most prestigious educational institutions.

They just publish advertorial for MCS. You’d think journalists would exercise some critical faculties.

They could at least make teasing comments about her Miranda Priestley sense of fashion, or tame jokes about her resemblance to Miss Honey in Roald Dahl’s Matilda or recherché references to the ‘Queen Semiramis’ of Cowley Place.

Anything!

In my article I had the temerity to suggest that far from building the school upon the rock, she had expanded it onto the sand. And now the rains are tumbling down.

I urged everyone associated with the school to reject Pike’s plan, which I argued, was to turn MCS into a secular, coeducational global franchise.

My alternative vision? I want the school to go back to educating the sons of Oxford’s professional classes as cheaply as possible, as it did in the C20th.

That’s a legitimate political intervention, isn’t it?

Why does nobody else want to stand up to her?

–

So why am I devoting large amounts of time to writing unpaid blogposts about my old school?

The reason is that I had a recent conversation with an ‘insider’.

I floated the idea that MCS’s existing model is not financially sustainable.

He shared my concerns.

No reason to lose heart.

To paraphrase a famous song: ‘Up from the ashes, up from the ashes, grow the lillies of success’.

(Incidentally when the new era comes I expect the chaps in the MCS Common Room to look just like the guys in this video.)

–

Like Helen Pike, I studied at Oxford University. I was trained to strive for glittering prizes.

Only I got a Third class degree.

Suddenly in the 1990s, it wasn’t enough to be an ‘Oxford’ man.

Only those with a 2:2 or above could get access to the graduate jobs that propel Oxford MAs effortlessly to the top.

Instead I spent 30 years observing my contemporaries from the sidelines as they’ve accumulated wealth and status.

And I’ve noticed patterns of complacency.

What makes an Oxford education unique?

You’re told not to just accept what people in authority tell you, you are encouraged to think for yourself.

In other words, an Oxford education gives you the confidence to do things – to contact anyone in public life.

That’s how we participate in a lively democratic society.

I’ve kept myself solvent and enjoyed great blessings in my life by writing letters to important people and persuading them to do things.

However, I’m often thwarted. There are a sizeable number of people in public life who don’t respond.

None of us have all the answers. Any person working in authority needs to welcome constructive suggestions and respond politely.

If they don’t, I ask myself: why are they in the job?

–

I started off with an open mind about Helen Pike’s appointment as Master.

I’m a speechwriter.

I wrote to congratulate Ms Pike on her new position as Master and sent her a copy of two of my books. One of which was a collection of jokes.

I enclosed a letter saying that they would be useful for the many speeches she would have to deliver in her new role.

She did not reply.

A few years later, I sent her a submission I wrote for the All Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) for Oracy talking about how I learned to speak in public at Magdalen College School, the Oxford Union and through an organisation called Toastmasters.

I made the polite suggestion that some of my ideas might be introduced to MCS.

She did not reply.

Then we had the lockdowns.

The school asked us to create diaries of our COVID experiences. I willingly participated.

In my diary I explained how my family made a mockery of all the measures, and how we could see others making a mockery of all the measures.

I ventured a daring thesis: the whole thing was the biggest medical fraud perpetrated on the public in living history.

As far as I know, other testimonies did not share this interpretation, but where would we be without diaries that shed fresh light on great events?

The archivist accepted my contribution graciously.

The cue for me to go berserk was when the alumni rep, Alan Cooper, circulated details of an Old Waynflete lunch with a requirement to show vaccine passports.

–

During this time, I had a friend in high places.

Mr Martin Reynolds CB CMG was Principal Private Secretary to Prime Minister Boris Johnson.

Mr Reynolds and I were pals at MCS.

Mr Reynolds became famous for organising parties in Downing Street during lockdown. He believed that the ‘parties’ were within the rules.

He messed up and paid a heavy price.

Mr Reynolds subsequently told me that a comment had reached him from MCS.

Someone at the school was said to have expressed relief that his involvement in ‘Partygate’ had caused no discernible reputational damage to the school.

He was hurt by that.

The school missed a priceless opportunity.

Here was an OW who could offer insights into what went on during a critical moment in the history of our country.

We learn very little from success, but a lot from failure. (‘There’s magic in the wake of a fiasco…’)

Inviting him to speak, letting the pupils quiz him about what actually happened, and why he did what he did, would have been fascinating for them.

As it was fascinating for me.

–

The final irritation came when my friend the author Jay Heinrichs said he was coming to the UK.

Jay is one of the world’s leading experts in rhetoric.

It would have been a privilege for him to speak in Oxford, a place he had never visited.

I asked him if he would craft a talk about the significance of MCS as a rhetorical humanist foundation, which had shaped Tyndale and other Renaissance statesmen.

He agreed and I contacted Alan Cooper to ask if he could speak to the English or Classics department.

Instead of sending me a two-line email telling me to get lost, he did not reply.

This embarrassed me because I said to my friend that I could make something happen and I couldn’t.

It motivated me to ask the question, what’s really going on at my old school?

–

There’s a video published on YouTube featuring the heads of the very top English schools.

It’s titled, ‘Rethinking the future of independent education’ and dates back to 2021.

It’s really sad. They all agree with each other. They’re all surrendering to technology and political fashion.

Not one reference to Christianity, which is the raison d’être of all these institutions.

 

 

The video features Tim Hands, the former headmaster of MCS from 2008 to 2016. And then the headmaster of Winchester College from 2016 to 2023.

If you watch Hands starts wringing his hands (geddit?) about the need to recognise Black Lives Matter.

As if that is any business of the British independent school system?

He says at one climactic moment, with the assent of his colleagues: ‘Education is a facilitator of social mobility.’

At this point I start foaming at the mouth, raving and rolling around the floor.

That’s ABSOLUTELY not the purpose of education (especially a ‘Christian’ one).

Hands is a shapeshifter. He’s an erudite, engaging and civilised man.

He stands up for the liberal humanist tradition, and then does cranky things like replacing the unique curriculum ‘div’ at Winchester with computer science.

But that’s being kind to him.

His baffling progressive side allowed a St Trinian’s takeover of two of our most civilised educational institutions.

How are we ever going to reverse that?

Maybe his hands were tied by the governors, but, like Boris Johnson during COVID, he could have resigned and walked away.

AI helped me to explain the question of ‘social mobility’:

‘Social mobility’ gives an elite institution a modern moral justification for selectivity. The hierarchy remains – Oxford remains prestigious, MCS remains expensive, certain occupations remain high-status – but the institution can argue that access to the upper reaches should depend less upon birth because it can work its own particular magic.

–

From humble beginnings, Helen Pike became Master of MCS.

What do we get in the way of storytelling from Ms Pike?

Nothing.

I haven’t found a public profile in which she identifies the schools she attended.

As far as I can tell, she does not reveal details of any teachers who spotted her potential.

She attended All Hallows Catholic High School followed by Cardinal Newman College in Preston.

These seem perfectly respectable schools, which anyone would have been proud to attend.

Other notable former pupils are publicly associated with both institutions.

Who spotted her talent? Who inspired her love of history?

Who encouraged a toothy Northern lass to have the chutzpah to apply for the grandest colleges in Oxford.

We don’t know.

Is it possible that ‘The House’ turned Helen into a snob?

I don’t think so.

And then a mischievous thought occurred to me. Suppose the governors congratulated themselves on an iconoclastic, trailblazing appointment?

Then an uncomfortable problem dawned on them.

If she started bragging about her journey from a comprehensive to Christ Church thanks to outstanding unworldly teachers, what message would that send to potential MCS parents?

Why would anyone pay tens of thousands of pounds to put their child through the school when it’s perfectly possible for someone like Helen to get there with just talent and determination?

–

This summer I went into my son’s primary school to organise a ‘Sword in the Stone’ ceremony.

First I had a sword and a stone made. Then I bought an expensive cape.

It took me a year to win the confidence of the deputy headmaster.

I did several iterations with some sixth formers and my fellow speechwriters.

It took six sessions to rehearse the children to have the cape draped over them, pull the sword out of the stone and make a short speech explaining who they were, what they had experienced so far in their lives and what they pledged to do in the future.

Ten Year 6 children took part in the ceremony which began with rousing New Age music.

I was struck how one small boy very much got into the spirit of the thing.

He put on his scout uniform, pulled out the sword, waved it around and told us clearly how much he enjoyed making macaroni cheese on scout camps.

In front of an audience of parents and teachers, he pledged that when he grew up he wanted to be a soldier and fight for his country.

I was so proud of him.

When I saw him the next day his face lit up. I knew the experience had changed him.

–

The argument about the future of MCS animates a fundamental philosophical difference about what it means to be a human being.

Should human beings just conform and consume?

That seems to be the unspoken ethos of the modern independent school.

Or should they wake up every morning and take action: fight for personal integrity, fight for a principled workplace and fight for a just and fair society?

That sword in the stone now sits in my office. Every once in a while, I draw it out and start waving it about.


Leave a reply