In December 2026, the European Speechwriter Network is organising a conference at the Leucorea in Wittenberg. The inspiration is that Wittenberg is where Shakespeare sent Hamlet to study rhetoric and rhetoric is a subject we want to revive. By coincidence, Saxony-Anhalt, the German state in which Wittenberg lies, has just given Alternative für Deutschland (AfD) a historic regional election victory.

Naively, as a Brit brought up on the free-speech principles of the Oxford Union, I thought this might be an opportunity to find out more about a rising political party. The unpleasant fallout illustrates a profound misunderstanding between Germans and the English, one that goes back decades. It also shows how Germany’s internal conflicts are spilling beyond its borders.

–

It’s Not Cricket

First, an anecdote from the summer of 2024. I boarded a train at Bournemouth bound for Southampton. A chap got on dressed like a well-to-do Englishman, complete with Panama hat. I soon discovered he was German – and clearly an Anglophile. I teased him by asking whether he was going to Lord’s to watch the cricket. We got chatting. He was a lawyer who taught at the University of Leipzig.

We bemoaned the dire state of England, and Bournemouth in particular. Then we moved on to the riots that followed the Southport killings.

‘Why do you allow it?’ he asked.

‘Allow what?’

‘Putin to meddle in the affairs of your country.’

‘Excuse me?’ I said. ‘I don’t think Putin’s got anything to do with it. There’s plenty of discontent in our own country to make people want to protest.’

I’d been hearing these kinds of alarming sentiments from educated Germans on a regular basis. Knowing I was getting off at Southampton, I didn’t hold back. I told him Germany was clearly a very messed-up place and that this paranoia about Putin was troubling.

–

The Germans are Special

Seventeen years ago, I set up an organisation that became the European Speechwriter Network.

In 2008, I went to Washington and experienced a sophisticated event organised by a Chicago-based communications company. A smart American called Lawrence Ragan had realised that speechwriters were lonely in their jobs. He had created an annual conference for them, which had matured over a couple of decades.

It was extremely well executed. I was impressed.

I decided to create a British version. It worked. What I discovered over time, however, was that it wasn’t primarily the British who wanted to come. It was European speechwriters who had to write in English and admired the Anglo-Saxon tradition of public speaking.

As the conference evolved, I took it on the road: first to Brussels, then Amsterdam, then Berlin. To host a conference in Berlin, I needed to cultivate German speechwriters.

The Germans were different. They had been running a network since 1998, founded by Helmut Schmidt’s former speechwriter, Thilo von Trotha.

I made contact and was introduced to a speechwriter called Willi Vogler, who had worked for Lufthansa. I invited him to speak at our conference in Oxford in spring 2014. He came and delivered a charming speech.

I decided to attend the German speechwriters’ conference in Berlin that autumn, hoping to recruit people for our own conference the following year. More than 100 people were there. Given Germany’s reputation as an advanced European country, I expected to be impressed. The organisation was run by a man called Vazrik Bazil.

The first red flag was the conference theme: ‘political correctness’. Not much scope, I thought, for the kind of wit Willi Vogler had displayed in Oxford.

Bazil was very welcoming, but everything was formal. As I sat down to listen to the speakers, I noticed some generously long coffee breaks in the programme.

I planned to use them to meet as many German speechwriters as possible. Then the conference began. The speakers were academics, not speechwriters. I got bored. At least there was the break to look forward to. But no: the organisers allowed the academics to run over time, eating up 20 minutes of the first 30-minute break.

From my Anglo-Saxon perspective, the conference was a shambles. There is one rule every speechwriter should know: keep to time. The invited speakers made a mockery of it.

Why didn’t the Verband ask its own members to speak?

There were other strange dynamics. Thilo von Trotha was an aristocrat, and he seemed to attract admirers for that reason.

The speeches were too abstract. They didn’t address the problems speechwriters actually face – the sort of shared difficulties that might have generated a relaxed fellowship among people doing the same challenging job.

I went home and wrote a harsh review on my blog.

It caused a diplomatic incident.

Vazrik Bazil wrote a reply and later resigned as President. As far as I can gather, the VRdS hasn’t organised a similar conference since.

I attended other German speechwriting conferences, organised by a private training company. I kept urging the organisers to widen their horizons: invite speakers from international organisations, connect with colleagues elsewhere in Europe, perhaps stop focusing exclusively on the German language. No impact. I found the Germans didn’t understand what it meant to be ‘clubbable’.

They did do one wonderful thing. A speechwriter called Peter Sprong led a tour of Berlin, visiting sites associated with major speeches delivered in the city. He covered Rosa Luxemburg, Martin Luther King, John F. Kennedy and others. I liked Peter Sprong. Later, he referred English-language work to me and became President of the Verband.

–

Can Speechwriters be Non-Political?

Over the years, I managed to bring Germans into European Speechwriter Network conferences. They loved visiting Oxford and Cambridge colleges. I also wrote a lively e-newsletter that didn’t shy away from politics.

During the lockdowns, I took a sceptical view. This irritated some German subscribers, but I shrugged it off. As a speechwriter, it’s my job to ‘argue the other side’.

After 15 years of patiently recruiting people to the Network, I stopped being a ghost at my own conferences. I began making short, sometimes provocative interventions.

I was deeply concerned about the direction Europe was taking.

One Dutch speechwriter friend was writing for senior figures at NATO. She was loving it and had become, to my mind, a distasteful warmonger. I’d known her as a much younger woman. I found the transformation upsetting.

Although I’d been a Remainer, the pandemic had radicalised me against the EU.

The October 7 attacks drove a wedge between me and a prominent Jewish member of our group. This member was charing a conference a month after the events.

We invited a Trades Union banner artist to speak. He showed slides of his banners being used by demonstrators for Palestine. The chair lost his temper with me during the event.

The fact that this artist also did one for us featuring Moses at the Burning Bush (thus displaying a commercial versatility that would be the envy of a writer for hire) did not appease him.

We’d weathered many political upheavals over the years, but it was becoming harder to hold a coalition together.

My instinct was to transcend these disputes by diving back into the past.

In 2025, I made a speculative visit to Wittenberg.

It was exactly what I’d hoped for: a beautiful, compact city you could walk across in 30 minutes, with quaint shops and church bells. The Leucorea, a small, austere former university building, could almost be mistaken for an Oxford college.

By another coincidence, I wandered into the Leucorea and discovered that a young German theologian, Dr Karl Tetzlaff, had recently launched a rhetoric retreat for local pupils from a prestigious school.

I had something similar in mind, perhaps for schoolchildren, university students or retired English graduates.

I believe in immersive education. A visit to Wittenberg could bring the Reformation alive for schoolchildren. The city also offers a rich literary inheritance, from Hamlet to Faust, and a way to explore the differences between East and West Germany.

I saw Wittenberg as a symbol of what Europe has forgotten.

Luther’s opponents regarded his ideas as dangerous, even heretical, yet arguments about them were conducted through disputations, pamphlets, sermons and public reasoning.

Europe did not become peaceful because everyone agreed. It learned, painfully and imperfectly, to create institutions in which disagreement could survive.

–

Putting Flesh on the Bones of an Idea

But where to begin?

I needed to organise a conference in Wittenberg with friends and associates, to show them its potential and build relationships with local archivists, scholars and people such as Dr Tetzlaff.

I set about inviting some of the outstanding speakers from previous European Speechwriter Network conferences.

I also hoped to work with the German speechwriters under Peter Sprong. But I remembered an earlier exchange with him about Russia.

He’d berated me for sceptical comments I’d made about the war in Ukraine.

I’d mentioned the 2008 NATO summit in Bucharest, when George W. Bush pushed for Ukraine and Georgia to be placed on a path towards NATO membership. Angela Merkel and Nicolas Sarkozy opposed an immediate Membership Action Plan, concerned, among other things, about the consequences for relations with Russia.

Yet the summit declaration said both countries would eventually become members.

I figured that, as speechwriters, it’s our job to research such complications. We shouldn’t simply take our lead from television news. I never reached any understanding with Sprong about the disagreement.

I wanted to work with the German speechwriters in Wittenberg, although what I saw as their Network’s parochialism didn’t fill me with optimism.

Nevertheless, a Zoom call with Peter Sprong was arranged. He tentatively agreed that the Verband would take part in the conference and contribute some sessions in German.

Just as I began promoting the conference, the AfD won the September 2026 state election in Saxony-Anhalt, although without an outright majority.

I knew the AfD was controversial. But the British had learnt painful lessons about the limits of excluding political movements from public discussion.

Sinn Féin and the IRA had caused immense problems during the 1980s and 1990s. The British government had tried to restrict the broadcast of their voices, yet eventually there had to be negotiations. Should we invite someone from the AfD? I wasn’t aware of the party itself advocating political violence.

As a Brit brought up among the free-thinking quadrangles of Oxford colleges, I thought the idea worth considering. We weren’t going to endorse the party. We could get the measure of its representatives by meeting them in person.

It was a matter of curiosity.

Who were these people, and what did they stand for?

–

Uproar!

A British speechwriter texted me at nine o’clock one evening to say I was sabotaging the Network by even considering inviting the AfD.

I replied that it was only a suggestion, but he became increasingly aggressive.

The next day, a British trainer called to say he would no longer come to Wittenberg to lead the rhetoric seminar we’d agreed on.

Two Germans from the Verband, Peter Sprong and his deputy Daniel Jungblut, weighed in: ‘Don’t do it! We will not work with you if you do.’

This vexed me. I hadn’t contacted a single member of the AfD. I’d merely floated the idea.

Over the years, I’d taken risks at conferences, inviting religious speakers and other unusual characters.

Sprong particularly annoyed me. A former member made the same allegation about him, that people make about me, that Sprong was pursuing his own political agenda.

I had plenty else going on in my life. I wrote an impulsive, intemperate email reply.

I accused Germany of having a ‘suicidal governing class that could not accept change’.

I quoted Jung – surely the Germans read Jung? – and said Germans needed to acknowledge their shadow. Sometimes what we find hardest to tolerate in others reflects something within ourselves.

I said the COVID years had revealed a strain of ruthless bureaucratic authoritarianism in Germany, suggesting that the country hadn’t learnt enough from its past.

I ended by saying Thatcher had been right: Britain should never have allowed Germany to reunify. As for Sprong, he would have to accept that the AfD existed.

As you can see, I made a spirited defence of my position.

–

Reflection

After a couple of weeks, I calmed down. I spoke to a more measured, diplomatic German who had booked for Wittenberg. During our Zoom conversation, he urged me not to invite the AfD.

I saw a rhetorical opportunity. I could graciously acknowledge that I’d made a mistake in floating the invitation – even though I hadn’t contacted anyone from the party – and ask the Verband to send speakers to explain why the AfD was regarded as so toxic. I could also invite them to outline a pragmatic response to the problems driving voters towards the party.

I sent this proposal to Peter Sprong and Daniel Jungblut.

They didn’t reply.

Every year, I attend the Battle of Ideas in London. It’s a wonderful gathering where free speech is taken seriously. This year, its organisers are also staging an event in Berlin, with Sabine Beppler-Spahl, a wry commentator on German affairs, involved.

I spoke to her. She too had tried to invite someone from the AfD to the Berlin event. The attempt had failed and caused difficulties.

I went back to Sprong and asked him to publicise the Berlin Battle of Ideas event to his members.

I told him about Sabine’s experience. I said the situation was a disaster for Germany and Europe. I reminded him of his wonderful Berlin walking tour, which had featured speeches associated with revolutionary moments.

Perhaps we were facing a similar moment. Wouldn’t it be wiser to prepare for change?

Why was Sprong refusing to cooperate? I knew he wouldn’t engage with the AfD. Now he wouldn’t engage with me either.

I said that this was one reason some well-educated people ended up voting for the ‘bad guys’: the supposed ‘good guys’ sometimes lacked even basic manners.

I copied in other Verband members so they could see what was happening.

Sprong replied that the VRdS had intended to participate in Wittenberg but would no longer do so because of my views. He asked me not to email him again.

I wrote back to say that, as President of a German professional body, he had a responsibility to handle disagreements better than this.


The Past is a Foreign Country: They Do Things Differently There.

I studied German at Brasenose College, Oxford from 1987 to 1991. Looking back, what I loved was the German appetite for extremes. My favourite rabbi once wrote that a ‘true study of humanity is inevitably a study of extreme paradox’.

I grew up under the strong influence of my mother’s Christian Science beliefs. She would say things like: ‘material reality doesn’t really exist; it’s just ‘an outpouring of thought’’.

It’s hardly surprising that an adolescent intrigued by this peculiar metaphysical perspective should have been drawn to German language and literature.

My tutor, Raymond Lucas, infected me with his enthusiasm for Heinrich von Kleist, a short-story writer and profound sceptic, with a tragic view of the world.

Kleist irritated Goethe, that smug representative of Weimar classicism.

Kleist’s characters inhabit unstable worlds. They discover that their moral and intellectual understanding of events is inadequate. During his ‘Kant crisis’, Kleist grappled with a disturbing question: can we ever know reality as it actually is?

His plays and stories examine such problems with humour and paradox.

Kleist may have influenced the course of my own life.

He wrote an essay, On the Gradual Formation of Thoughts While Speaking (Über die allmähliche Verfertigung der Gedanken beim Reden).

His argument was that we don’t necessarily think first and then speak. We discover what we think through the act of speaking.

As a speechwriter, my love of rhetoric is rooted in an obsession with that act.

I believe an idea on paper has limited value. It comes fully to life when converted into embodied speech, shared with and understood by another person, who may then act upon it.

My passion for the subject has led me to study psychotherapy and movements such as the Oxford Group, which helped give rise to Alcoholics Anonymous.

I believe in the healing power of rhetoric and the necessity of honest conversation. Yet these principles have often been absent from my experience of everyday life in England.

I grew up in a family where nobody spoke the truth about anything. I have an uneasy affection for English institutions, in which lies and hypocrisy so often prevail.

The redeeming qualities of the English used to be their deep ambivalence towards institutions and their keen sense of humour.

Take The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp. We meet a character who deeply admires German culture. He wants to love Germany as he loves his German friend.

But the film also shows how a bluff Englishman struggles to understand the dark politics of a resentful, defeated nation. His upbringing has taught him to believe that decent people can always find a way to get along.

When we deal with Germany, we think we’re dealing with Goethe: a principled country that prizes order and rationality. But perhaps we sometimes encounter something more like the world of Kleist: unstable, paradoxical and prone to destructive extremes.

Our assumptions of mutual understanding may be dangerously complacent.

Growing up in Oxford, attending the Oxford Union, staging political conferences and studying movements that help troubled individuals find sanity and serenity have all given me a robust idealism.

I consider myself a pragmatic Brit who knows what is possible when people are brought together to debate and explore ideas.

I also recognise that I may be a Colonel Blimp myself. I’ve wandered onto a minefield that could blow up a business I’ve spent 17 years building.

I’ve run up against a German political culture I don’t fully understand – and perhaps one that doesn’t understand me.

I’m losing friendships cultivated over many years. It’s painful.

Are we living through a Stefan Zweig moment, when civilised engagement becomes impossible?

A handful of us will be in Wittenberg this Christmas to see what we can do about it. You’re welcome to join us.

The Spirit of Wittenberg Conference takes place at the Leucorea from 16-18 December.

Register here. 

If anyone wishes to challenge or take issue with any of the sentiments expressed in this article, please exercise your right to reply.

 


Leave a reply