I live in Bournemouth. We used to host the party political conferences. I loved going along, whatever the party. Over three days you could wander round talking to people, listening to lectures and watching the big shots mingle amongst us.
For several years, the Wellington Festival of Education has caught my eye.
I’m not a schoolteacher, but I am in the business of teaching speechwriting to professionals. One of the few clearly defined policies of the Starmer Government is ‘oracy’. That is to say, the teaching of public speaking. I saw this as relevant to the work I do, so I applied to speak at the Wellington conference on the subject.
I didn’t get selected, but they were very kind and they sent me a free ticket for the trouble I took to apply.
I decided to book a hotel and spend two days in Crowthorne getting the measure of the contemporary educational establishment.
Then suddenly 4th July became a portentous day. It was the day of the General Election 2024.
It was weird for me because it was predicted that Bournemouth would turn red. This seemed to me unthinkable. Tobias Ellwood and Sir Conor Burns surely could never lose in Bournemouth?
I arrived in Crowthorne station where there is a sign, ‘Home of Wellington College’. This made me feel a little uneasy, perhaps because of what was in the air.
Do you really want to brag so openly about the existence of the College? New political winds are blowing. I’d keep a low profile if I were you.
Those of us heading for the festival immediately found a rank of Wellington ‘branded’ minibuses waiting to transport us to the College.
As we went down the stately road to the school overlooking the beautifully manicured cricket pitch, again I felt uneasy.
The country that day was going to vote for a party that was promising to levy VAT on school fees, a clear political challenge to the status, and even the existence of these schools.
The campus was filled with tents and stalls. It was just like a party political conference. You could put your head round the doors and see if you wanted to join in.
I headed straight to the ‘oracy’ tent.
I’d done my homework before.
‘Oracy’ is an attempt by modern educationalists to rediscover some of the elements of rhetoric.
Peter Hyman was a speechwriter for Tony Blair, and when his job came to an end he decided he wanted to challenge the exam factory curriculum. He set up a new school called School 21 in the East End to try to introduce oracy to change the way children were assessed.
Hyman seemed to me to be undertaking a very admirable quest.
I sat down in a very luxurious polythene tent and listened in to a teacher advocating for more talk in the classroom.
That seemed to me to be rather wishy-washy. At the end of her lecture, I asked the teacher what the intellectual idea behind oracy was. I mentioned Peter Hyman the founder of the school was a speechwriter, like I am.
I didn’t get a very satisfactory answer.
A panel discussion followed. It seemed to me a little pointless – a defence of whether children should be able to use filler words like, ‘like’.
When it came to asking questions, we were invited to submit them via an app.
This was an example of how technology can be adopted just for technology’s sake. Why not let people put up their hand and we can see what they’re asking? It’s a lot simpler and more engaging.
I listened to another speaker talk about oracy. Geoff Barton, a former headmaster, was clearly a political player.
He’s the Chair of the Oracy Education Commission, which sounds like, and indeed claims to be, an independent commission. But I can find no evidence of any independence. Judging by Geoff’s words and tweets, he’s a Labour cheerleader.
I got no idea from Geoff Barton what the ‘principles’ were behind oracy.
He said it didn’t mean that there would be a debating club in every school in the country. He did say that if they were debating climate change, it would be led by the science teacher and the geography teacher.
I challenged Mr Barton on this at the end of the talk.
Did he really say that the children could only debate climate change within parameters set by certain staff?
He said to me that he hadn’t meant that, but he didn’t have the time to tell me what he did mean. I then said to him that debating was rather old-fashioned, had he ever been to a Toastmasters meeting? He said he’d heard of it, before rushing away to another meeting.
I enjoyed a good exchange with a master from Eton who had a stall marketing EtonX – a digital teaching resource available for free to state schools.

Wellington has a beautiful chapel. But they’re building a new mindfulness and wellness centre. Maybe this is God’s way of telling us they’ve got too much money?
He was an articulate advocate of his wares. I suggested that this was crumbs from the table.
Eton was merely trying to pre-empt political moves against them. Their pupils wouldn’t be doing much digital learning.
We had a conversation about how Eton now takes boys from inner city communities and turns them into scholars.
Maybe because I knew a change of Government was imminent, I pulled a face. Schools can’t play God.
And indeed the next conversation was about God.
I went into the tent which exhibited Wellington’s international franchise. They have eight schools around the world places like Asia and India. I was intrigued because in my business, the people interested in learning about rhetoric are not British, but foreign.
I said to a lady in their marketing department, ‘I went to a school like Wellington in the 1980s. It was Crimean war conditions. The food was awful. We had Bible readings every morning, prayers, choral music and Divinity. It was like an Anglican madrasa. That indifference to material comforts has stayed with me. How do you export that aspect of the school to Shanghai or Puna?’
‘Oh we don’t do any of that any more. They just come to us with their requirements and we give them the brand and the uniform.’
‘Oh,’ I said, looking at the pictures of the state-of-the art multi-million pound campuses.
I didn’t have the courage to say it, but I thought to myself, if you can call a school a brand, that’s a red flag.
And, of course, looking around at the stunning Wellington facilities, it suddenly became clear how damaging the commercial expansion of education has become. Money is no object.
Here were thousands of teachers listening to talks on wishy-washy, over-politicised issues relating to education. The majority seemed to be from the state sector, or pseudo-non-profit commercial enterprises; I didn’t run into many private school teachers.
Is the Festival of Education a PR exercise by the private schools to ingratiate themselves with their political opponents? I’m tempted to guess so.
By chance, a few weeks earlier I had been visiting a new Jewish yeshiva in Vienna.
We spent an hour-and-a-half discussing the Torah and the workings of Providence. The boys there were leaving their families, but the desks and classrooms were as austere as the ones I remembered in my school.
If you want to find out what a real education is, I suggest you listen to some Hasidic rabbis on YouTube.
But we know this.
The best schools came out of the monasteries, they were not at all interested in helping you ‘fulfil your potential’. They taught their pupils to worship and to try to discern the will of God. That only requires a teacher, a book, a blackboard and a desk.
The boarding pupils at Wellington pay £17,370 per term. And they get the best of everything, because if you’re competing with other schools, that’s the way a business operates.
If Eton’s got a symphony orchestra, we’ve got to have one.
But maybe if they ditched the Michelin-star chef who cooks the school dinners, they could lower the prices.
Here’s a thought: education is not a business – and getting a job is a by-product of a good education, not the purpose of it.
The last lecture of the afternoon was from Will Ord, who runs a consultancy called Thinking Education.
Mr Ord gave a talk on the art of arguing. He wasn’t part of the oracy crowd, but here was a man who gave us some idea of what a ‘principled’ education looks like.
He asked us what Darwin was doing in 1838.
There was mutterings about how he was working on the Origin of Species, but the answer was that he was working out whether he was going to get married or not.
He drew up a list of arguments for and arguments against, and Mr Ord quoted to us some of them.
We had just lived through an election campaign where we were supposed to have debated the political issues facing the country.
But there was no proper debate on foreign policy, the future of the NHS or the consequences of our environmental policies.
That made what Mr Ord was saying about the art of argument, how there are two sides to every issue, especially poignant.
His audience grasped that.
After a day of blazing sunshine, I went back to my hotel.
I woke up at 5.30am to follow the results and I realised the unthinkable had happened.
Bournemouth had turned red. Over 200 Conservative MPs lost their seats. Suddenly something that had looked so solid, the Conservative Party’s hold on the country, had melted into air.
And that Conservative Party provided key support as the public schools expanded, took in foreign pupils and continued to justify their charitable status.
I wanted to head back to Wellington but it had started to rain.
The new political landscape made me ponder the future of Wellington College from another perspective.
We’re gearing up for military conflict with Russia and China. Russian and Chinese pupils have swollen the rolls of schools like Wellington.
How’s that going to be, to coin a phrase, ‘sustainable’?
I had my breakfast in the Wellington College equivalent of Costa. It was raining hard by now.
The effervescence of the first day of the festival had gone.
I forced myself to go to one last lecture on ‘Laughology.’ As a speechwriter, I was interested in humour.
It was packed. But it was infantile. When the speaker told us we have millions of neurons in our heads, I’d had enough, and walked out.
As a coda to this experience, I paid a visit to the open evening for our local grammar school.
There was of course a big emphasis on science subjects.
I approached an English master. I asked him, do you do debating? He said they did. I asked him what he would do if a child questioned climate change in a debate. He said, without a beat, ‘Of course I would not tolerate climate change denial.’
I headed to the foreign language teachers and bonded with them. They were doing their best. I asked them about French exchanges. They said they didn’t do those any more because of the complexity of the DBS checks. A sign of the times.
We commiserated the fact that people don’t realise that learning languages is not just to speak when you’re on holiday, it’s a cultural, linguistic and social education. (If we’d continued to support the compulsory learning of modern languages, would we need to teach vacuous substitutes like ‘oracy’?)
I found myself in the foyer of the school, and someone pointed me towards the Deputy Head.
She was a linguist.
I asked her why there wasn’t much emphasis on foreign languages.
She said that it was harder to get top grades in foreign languages, so they didn’t push them, but there was a new GCSE coming which would provide a list of vocabulary. The examiners would pledge not to include any words in the exams that were not on the list.
I said that didn’t sound good.
She said it was a long list.
I then asked why they didn’t teach Latin.
She said the parents expected school to give them qualifications that would help them find jobs. She’d done Latin but it hadn’t done much for her.
I pointed out that my sons were upstairs examining lambs’ hearts. They were learning about the atrium and the ventricle, all Latin words.
Latin links up law, horticulture, medicine – it’s the substratum to all academic study.
To make a point, I added that we did not want under any circumstances to be governed by scientists again. We can recall just a few years ago we endured two years of medical dictatorship at the behest of scientists.
The deputy head said she didn’t want to discuss politics and that she had to be somewhere else.
I got home and talked about it with my wife.
The kind of education I had is no longer available in the private or the state sector.
We’ll have to teach our sons principles. Like, always respect and listen to different opinions from your own, however crazy they may sound.
Your beliefs will change over the course of your life, help others along their journey.
Always list arguments for and against. That goes especially when analysing the causes of wars, discussing the NHS and any political measures to deal with meteorological events.
Always question and challenge authority. (Especially scientists, in our era, as they are almost always dependent on their institutions or professional bodies for their livelihood, so can’t think independently).
And always listen to your own conscience.
In my commonplace book I’ve copied out three reasons why businesses fail.
One of them is, they know what their purpose is, but they’re not doing it.
For that reason, we can look forward to some dramatic changes in education in the coming decade.


Leave a reply