Quentin Letts calls him the matinée idol from Bournemouth. My eyebrows were raised as I absorbed the collapse of the Conservative Party at the General Election, but I was truly shocked that Tobias Ellwood lost his seat.
At these moments, the mind goes back to the beginning.
In 2005, I got to know Tobias when he arrived in Bournemouth. I was standing as a councillor and I volunteered to work with him on his campaign.
We’d go out in his car and talk. We shared a desire to renew Conservative politics in the local area.
I was impressed by the way he said he was against the Iraq war. He contacted Central Office to ask them if he could put that on his campaign literature and they allowed him to.
At the time, I’d just finished reading Lewis Baston’s biography of a top Tory of the 1970s, Reggie Maudling
I remember trying to tell Tobias about the gruesome last pages of the book when Reggie ends up mired by scandal, addiction and remorse at the end of a distinguished career.
But Tobias was brash, eager and unreflective, he wasn’t ready to contemplate then how even the most distinguished careers in politics end unpleasantly.
With his military background, he cultivated a commando image. He knew how to keep a small team motivated for a couple of hours. For all his bluster, Tobias was a sensitive and likeable chap.
When he won the seat, his team drew T-O-B-I-A-S in large letters on the sand on Bournemouth beach. There was every reason to believe that he’d be in the seat as long as he wanted to be.
In 2009 I launched a new initiative, a UK Speechwriters’ Guild.
Tobias was the first speaker at the first conference which took place in Bournemouth. He did a fantastic job. Then he came back a year later and gave an even better speech on how he used a commonplace book to enrich his speeches.
After his second election win, I approached Tobias with a friend to launch a ‘think tank’ for Bournemouth.
We were frustrated by the lack of imagination in the way the town was run and we asked him to help us set up a group to do ‘blue sky’ thinking for the area.
We wanted it to be cross-party. We developed a format.
With Tobias’s endorsement we came up with plans for a monorail from the airport to the beach, an iconic building, an arts centre, a waterbus and many other fanciful projects.
It turned out that our first key objective, the unification of Bournemouth, Poole and Christchurch into one council, did happen in 2019 (although not directly because of our efforts).
Tobias was pleased with the success of what was called Conurbation 2050 and he made it his own.
It was obvious that the Conservative Party by 2015 was going in a Eurosceptic direction, which neither I nor Tobias agreed with.
I fell out with the local Conservatives, but I remained on good terms with Tobias.
I joined the Liberal Democrats.
I still attended Conurbation 2050. Tobias could chair a meeting with good humour. He was a genial constituency MP.
Then came the Brexit referendum, which caused division and strife within the Conservative Party.
Tobias had occupied ministerial office and became a household name when he rushed to the assistance of police officer Keith Palmer after a terrorist attack.
But then we had the rise of Boris Johnson.
Tobias seemed to be in two minds.
He didn’t like Boris, but he didn’t like not being a minister either. Bizarrely, instead of rebelling, he became an over-zealous supporter of some Government policies.
When the hysteria mounted around a ‘virus’ in early 2020, he could have chosen to be a voice of sanity like Desmond Swayne MP. (Anyone who really cared about the future of the country knew that lockdowns would cause immeasurable damage).
Instead he used his media profile to enforce the lockdowns and ‘safety’ measures, rather than caution against them.
Tobias was on the television berating people for coming down to Bournemouth to enjoy the sunshine in May 2020.
Suddenly he started saying that the lockdowns would not end until there was a vaccine. Where did that narrative come from?
He said on Sky, ‘People should get vaccinated, or else.’, ‘Or else what, Tobias?’ I yelled at the TV.
Those of us who knew how medicine works, were bemused by how the top echelons of Government completely forgot the fundamental principles of medical ethics.
Tobias rode the repressive wave created by the medical populists who just loved acting out, while there was scant evidence, outside of the media, of any medical catastrophe that merited the measures imposed.
Moderate Tobias had turned into a contemptible authoritarian.
Then when the Ukraine war started, Tobias became a fixture on TV calling for an increase in defence spending.
He told us how evil Mr Putin was, and how we were already at war with Russia, we should put boots on the ground and sink ships in the Black Sea.
In Dorset we were all worrying about rocketing electricity bills, was there really any interest in the geopolitical tussle that was going on between Russia and NATO?
I went to a Conurbation 2050 breakfast with Tobias in October 2022. The breakfasts were supposed to be for discussion of local issues.
I was focusing on my poached egg when I suddenly overheard Tobias explaining that if Russia used nuclear weapons, NATO would respond accordingly.
Here was Tobias being as cavalier about nuclear war as he was about the wrecking of the British economy during the lockdowns.
I spoke up. I reminded Tobias of that man I had known in 2005: thoughtful, open, keen to be in touch with public opinion.
Did he know military history? It would be impossible for Ukraine to win a war against Russia.
At that time he didn’t even have the Conservative Whip, so he was under no obligation to warmonger.
A deft politician would have accused me of being a Putin stooge and embarrassed me in front of the other guests.
Instead Tobias said, ‘How dare you speak to me like that?’
Some wag pointed out that we were at Conurbation 2050: the way Tobias was talking we weren’t going to be around in 2050.
He lost control of the situation and afterwards threatened to ban me from the breakfasts.
It was a sad end to a friendship.
The BCP elections of 2023 proved to be ominous.
The number of Conservative councillors across the three towns dropped from 36 to 12.
That meant that Tobias wouldn’t have many troops to leaflet for him in the General Election.
I’m the kind of person who likes to write to my MP.
Twenty years ago, I’d write and a few weeks later a beautiful cream envelope with a portcullis logo on it would drop through the letterbox.
I’d get a reply written on vellum paper thanking me for bringing this important issue to attention. And it would be signed in ink by the MP.
I’d feel chuffed for the rest of the day.
Last autumn I got emails from the school inviting my sons to have vaccinations. I’ve worked as a professional writer for 30 years.
The NHS emails used dirty compliance tactics to make anyone wishing to opt out feel as if they wanted to risk the lives of their elderly relatives.
We’d had enough of such propaganda during the lockdowns so I wrote a physical letter to Tobias, my local MP, to complain.
I received a long screed of email from his assistant telling me that I was a vexatious crank.
Around the same time Tobias released a video about how life was looking up in Afghanistan under the Taliban, which lost him his position on the Defence Select Committee.
After that Tobias, the intrepid commando, started complaining that MPs weren’t safe.
If Tobias is so willing to propose that our armed forces go into combat to defend a democratic Ukraine, perhaps he should have shown similar courage in the exercise of his own duties. After all his finest moment was when he showed he was prepared to walk into danger.
I calculated that every time he appeared on television he was losing votes.
He also stopped allowing people to make comments on his X feed.
Because they rarely have to confront the public in live situations, I noticed that MPs on social media convince themselves that all the negative responses they get on their posts are from deranged haters.
Rory Stewart said in his biography that MPs stop thinking when they get elected. After about ten years they completely stop listening as well.
It’s hard for any MP to keep remain sane in a safe seat for longer than three election cycles.
At the hustings, Tobias was the most impressive speaker on the podium, but the self-confidence had gone.
He should have called it a day before the election, but it must be terribly hard to give up a safe seat.
The polls were saying it was lost, but I never really believed it, and he probably didn’t either.
Then Tom Hayes, the rather wooden Labour ingénu, did the impossible, he won Bournemouth East.
It was amusing to hear Tobias say in his farewell speech, ‘I accept this result’.
To underline that fact, he said it twice.
At the beginning of the campaign, Tobias had drawn his name in the sand for his election literature.
Now the tide had washed it away.
He has published a couple of melancholy videos promising a return, but I suspect Bournemouth’s matinée idol has appeared in his last picture.
What a showreel! He did the state some service. He had his 15 minutes of fame. He had the gift of being able to cheer us all up when performing the role of MP.
As for becoming Prime Minister, he could have been a contender.
I’m thankful that he brought his imprimatur to the UK Speechwriters’ Guild. He’s certainly polished his own speechmaking skills during his time in office.
He wasn’t a conventional, risk-averse, boring MP.
Bournemouth was lucky to have him, but I’m now relieved, as evidently many other Bournemouth residents are, that he has returned to civvy street.
I noticed few hours after the election results were in that the new Labour MPs Tom Hayes and Jessica Toale posted a video on X. They were standing next to each other at the Bournemouth Pride festival introducing themselves.
It was astonishing, because it was so counter-cultural. Tobias and Conor Burns couldn’t stand to be in the same room as each other even before they were elected.
That was how things rolled in the Conservative Party.
The party used to attract professionals of all kinds and hosted garden parties, coffee mornings and dinners.
That culture was ailing before the election, I expect it will struggle to survive now that Labour MPs have taken Bournemouth and Poole.
Leave a reply